Strategy development and execution is an expensive exercise. Its failure can cost even more. In particular, it can cost the careers of the accountable managers.
Our strategy crash test is used to predict if the strategy may fail under the pressures of execution. It enables our clients to understand where and what may be done to increase the probability of success. To understand what the consequences of a failed strategy are, see below.
READ NEXTStrategy Execution
Low success rates for strategy execution are well-known, well-described and well-analysed. Key statistics remind us about the issues with strategy execution:
Social Bottom Line Management: Processes
At En-Sync 8020, we utilise the following key processes to ensure an effective management of Social Bottom Line Management:
of well-formulated strategies succeeded due to poor execution
of successfully executing companies, effectively translate their strategy into operational mechanisms
of successfully executing companies, limit the number of strategic initiatives they focus on
of successfully executing companies, build
budgets / resources around strategy
of executives, fail within the first 18 months of being promoted or hired
Expensive Strategy Failures
Strategy Development and Execution is an expensive exercise for any company. Failures are very costly, including the careers of executives. Executives listed some other prevalent costs in a survey conducted by En-Sync 8020:
Cost of strategy development
Loss of investment in strategy execution
Lost and unrealised opportunities
Loss in market capitalisation
Redundancies
caused by Executives
Strategy “Crash” Test
En-Sync 8020 assist companies to deliberately “crash” a strategy (or various strategic scenarios), under controlled conditions, in order to evaluate and improve its ability to withstand an execution and reduce, number of strategic outputs achieved by finding out the strategy’s breaking points under pressure of strategy execution.
Strategy “Crash” Test: Process
Our practice which includes the following key steps shows that the best sequence of actions to “crash” test your strategy with best results at optimised cost:
Identify strategy or its critical path for Strategy “crash” Test
Collect data on the parameters of Strategy “crash” Test
Identify and analyse scenarios for strategy execution with the data collected
Simulate consequences of the strategy execution with current parameters
Identify the parameters of the strategy to be improved
Strategy “Crash” Test: Parameters
The analysis of strategy failures, by En-Sync 8020, shows a set of frequent and most repeated causes of strategy execution failure that are categorised into THREE main groups of parameters:
Strategy
The way a strategy is developed and described from the start can doom its execution
Poor organisational conditions that lead to errors in the strategy execution and non-delivery of some or all the strategic objectives
Lack of positive support from the employees and other stakeholders to support the strategy and its objectives
“Crash” Parameters: Quality of Strategy
Research on the quality of the strategy, by En-Sync 8020, uncovered FOUR key qualitative parameters that can “crash” the execution of the strategy and its success:
Value Chain Complexity Level (8 Levels of complexity)
Business Strategy Complexity level (8 Levels of complexity)
Match between Value Chain Complexity and Business Strategy Complexity
Strategy has three types of objectives: economic, social and environmental
Economic, Social and Environmental Objectives of the strategy has the same level of complexity
Economic targets match % of economic bottom line increase
Non-negotiable goals
Strategy Value Drivers
Critical Success Factors
Critical Tasks
Outputs (Quantity, Quality, Time)
Resources per critical task
Strategy has milestones that match the complexity level of the strategy.
For example, the strategy of Level 5 complexity must have:
10 year, 5 year, 2 year, 1 year, 3 months milestones at least
“Crash” Parameters: Execution Capability
Even the most perfect strategy can fail if the company lacks the execution capability to deliver the strategy and every strategy task (at least critical ones). Our research identified THREE types of execution capabilities:
Critical tasks of the strategy differ in the complexity level of work required to deliver the outputs, e.g.:
- Level 2 Task requires a business process to have a successful delivery
- Level 3 Task needs a mature functional system, etc.
Organizational roles differ in level of complexity (8 levels of complexity)
- Every critical task must have an accountable role
- Level of role accountable for a task must match the level of work complexity of the task
- The role accountable for the critical task must have the authorities required
Every critical task of the strategy has the profile of the competency requirements that a role holder must have to deliver the tasks effectively:
- Skilled knowledge
- Experience
- Qualifications
- Values
- Information processing capability
“Crash” Parameters: Strategy Acceptance
Acceptance of the strategy by its stakeholders is a critical set of parameters, that are frequently forgotten and not measured, but taken into account by En-Sync 8020 in the strategy “crash” test.
Strategy Acceptance is positive intention of strategy stakeholders to support the strategy and its objectives.
All the strategy stakeholders are identified (employees, shareholders, communities, unions, etc.)
Support from every stakeholder group must be clearly defined using context of support, action, target of support, time for support
Acceptance levels by various stakeholder groups are quantified, measured and analysed
Strategy “Crash” Test: Benefits
In general, “crash” testing the strategy before going live with it reveals its constraints and allows the company to refine its real life approach to successful strategy execution.
Increased % of strategic objectives achieved and critical tasks completed with the outputs expected
Optimised cost of capital invested to support the strategy
execution / implementation
ROCE
Improved Return on Capital Employed (ROCE) in the strategy execution and implementation
Reduced turnover among the managers accountable for strategy execution and implementation
Accelerated Learning Technology
En-Sync 8020 utilises a combination of accelerated learning, dynamic factor modelling, economic, social and environmental value drivers that allow active learning and trial & errors in a safe simulated environment to disrupt old perceptions and ideas about the single economic bottom line strategy.
3BL Accelerated Learning & Development allows the executives of the companies to see the consequences of ignoring the triple bottom line equilibrium today, in the future whilst learning about the benefits of changing their perceptions and behaviours about the triple bottom line management.